Repowering is what engine remanufacturers call it. Replacing an engine with a new, remanufactured engine or rebuilt engine can add years to a vehicle's life and save thousands of dollars over what it might cost to buy another vehicle.
Zero percent financing and factory rebates can make a new car or truck seem very attractive. But when you add it all up, it is almost always cheaper to keep an existing vehicle even if it requires major repairs.
Replacing an engine is obviously a major repair that requires a sizable investment in a vehicle. For some older vehicles, the cost of replacing the engine may be more than the vehicle is worth. Yet many owners will have the engine replaced anyway because they do not want to trade vehicles or they owe too much on the vehicle to trade it.
An engine that is properly maintained with regular oil and filter changes, changing the spark plugs, timing belt and coolant at specified intervals, etc., should last 100,000 to 150,000 miles or more. But many engines are not properly maintained. Oil and filter changes are put off too long. The coolant is never changed. Nobody remembers to replace the timing belt. Consequently, after thousands of miles of neglect, the engine falters or suffers a variety of fatal ills. It starts to burn oil. It fouls spark plugs and misfires. It burns a valve. It overheats. It blows a head gasket. The head cracks. The oil pressure drops dangerously low. Warning lights come on. It makes rapping, clattering, ticking noises. It is hard to start. It seizes up and refuses to run.
When the engine finally reaches the end of the road, a painful choice has to be made: spend whatever it takes to fix or replace the original engine, or get rid of the vehicle and buy another. Either way it is going to cost money. A car dealer won't give much for a trade-in that has a bad engine. The only way to get rid of a car or truck with a bad engine is to junk it or sell it as a mechanic's special or fixer-upper. Either way, it won't sell for much money.
Replacing the engine on a vehicle that is more than 12 to 14 years old is usually not worth the cost, unless the vehicle is a classic, an antique or has special value. Engine replacement makes the most economic sense on vehicles that are four to 12 years old, and are still in good condition and worth repairing.
Replace Your Engine or Have Your Old Engine Rebuilt?
The first step in replacing an engine is to confirm the old engine is beyond fixing or requires so much labor to repair that it is better to replace it. Many internal problems can be repaired without having to completely overhaul the engine - provided the rest of the engine is still in relatively good condition. That includes replacing a blown head gasket, a broken or rounded camshaft, a cracked piston, worn valve guides, burned or bent valves, a cracked head or even a spun bearing. But if the block is cracked, can't be repaired without major machine work or has to be completely disassembled, the cost of parts and labor may tip the scale in favor of replacing the engine.
Replacement options include a used engine from a salvage yard (risky but usually the cheapest alternative), a remanufactured engine (short block or long block), or a new "crate" engine from the original equipment manufacturer. Good used engines for many vehicles are hard to find, and the salvage yard warranty rarely covers installation labor. A safer bet is to replace the old engine with a new or remanufactured engine tha tis backed by a performance warranty as well as an installation labor warranty.
Replacement Engines and Emissions Compliance
One thing you have to keep in mind with all late-model engine installations is emissions compliance. The replacement engine must be identical to the original so all the required emissions controls and sensors can be installed the same as before. Some engines may have special camshafts, heads or pistons that require a perfect match to meet emissions. Close enough may not be good enough on some of these applications.
Also note, if you are buying a used engine or a remanufactured engine from an offshore supplier for an import vehicle, the engine many not be equipped with U.S emission controls or have the same sensor hookups as your old engine. This can sometimes cause installation issues, or may prevent you from passing an emissions test. So make sure the engine either meets U.S. emission rules, or can be easily modified to accept the same sensor and emission control hookups as your old engine BEFORE you buy it.
Engine Performance Upgrades
Another option to consider when replacing an engine is upgrading performance. If more horsepower is wanted, various performance modifications and add-ons may be included, such as a hotter camshaft, higher compression pistons, a performance intake manifold, stroker crankshaft, oversized pistons, or aftermarket cylinder heads with larger valves, etc.
Another option is to install a ready-to-run "crate" engine. Many engine builders offer mild to wild performance engines that are built to almost any specifications. Crate engines typically cost 20 to 25% less than custom built engines, and are available online and from a variety of sources. The engine may be a long block with or without valve covers and oil pan, or it may include an intake manifold, water pump and carburetor or fuel injection system.
For street use, a stage 1 upgrade typically includes a hotter cam, more compression, bigger valves and/or slightly modified head(s), and add 50 to 70 horsepower over the stock engine. A Stage 2 upgrade might bump up the horsepower 70 to 100 hp or more, while a stage 3 or 4 would be more of a serious performance engine.
If you are installing a performance engine, keep in mind that more horsepower means more stress on the drivetrain and cooling system. Additional upgrades also may be needed to handle the extra power such as a larger radiator, beefed up transmission or clutch.
Another benefit of buying a crate engine is no waiting for a machine shop to disassemble, clean, inspect, remachine and rebuild your old engine (a process that often takes up to a week or more depending on the workload in the shop). The only delay with a crate engine is the time it takes the warehouse distributor or engine rebuilder to ship you the engine (which typically adds $150 to $300 to the cost). Many create engines are sold outright with no exchange needed, but others do involve a core charge of $300 to $500 or more if you are not returning your old engine.
The sky is the limit as to how much you can spend on a performance crate engine. The price of a performance crate engine typically starts a little higher than that of a stock replacement engine, and goes up exponentially depending on how many cubic inches and how much horsepower and torque you want. If you want a 603 cubic inch Chevy big block V8 that makes 850 plus horsepower, it's only a matter of writing a bigger number on your check. The large displacement, high horsepower custom-built crate engines typically start around $9000 and go up from there. But most of the Ford and Chevy factory built performance crate engines are in the $5000 to $8000 range.
A popular upgrade for a stock 350 Chevy V8 is a 383 stroker motor that includes a longer stroke crankshaft that produces 340 to 400 or more horsepower depending on the cylinder heads, camshaft and compression ratio). The cost may range from $3000 for a "budget" version of the engine up to $7000 or more for a ready-to-race motor built with top quality, name brand aftermarket racing parts.An important point to keep in mind with respect to performance engines is that durability and reliability are just as important as cubic inches and raw horsepower. Forged pistons, rods and steel crankshafts cost much more than their cast iron counterparts, but are often necessary to provide the durability demanded in a racing environment -- or even a street engine that may be used occasionally on a drag strip.
Other factors that affect the selling price of a performance crate engine include the labor that goes into blueprinting and machining the cylinder heads (ccing the combustion chambers, porting, flow testing, etc.), special work done on the block (grinding to increase clearances for a stroker crank, replacing pressed-in oil plugs with threaded plugs), balancing (which includes adding heavy metal on a stroker crank), line boring, milling, stress relieving or other special procedures that would not usually be done to a stock engine. The more time and effort that goes into prepping and building the engine, the higher its price -- and the better its performance and durability (hopefully!).
Many (but not all) performance crate engines are dyno tested after they have been assembled. Dyno testing allows the engine builder to make sure everything was put together correctly and the engine has proper compression and oil pressure. It also allows them to control the critical engine break-in process (which reduces warranty problems). It also allows them to verify the engine's power output. The dyno sheet that comes with the engine shows its actual torque and horsepower curves, which is much more credible than advertising claims in a sales brochure.
Engine Installation Tips
Before you roll the engine hoist into place to drop in the new or rebuilt motor, here are some things that should be done or checked before the engine is installed:
ENGINE STARTUP AND BREAK-IN
During the test drive:
After the test drive:
Remanufactured & Crate Engine Suppliers:ATK Engines (import engines)
Crate Engine Depot (GM engines)
Edelbrock Crate Engines
Ford Performance Engines
EngineworldUSA.com (Used Japanese engines from Japan)
Mopar Performance Engines
Jasper Remanufactured Engines
Precision Engine Rebuilders
Powersource Rebuilt Engines
RAM Remanufactured Engines
World Products Remanufactured Engines
More Engine Repair Articles:Tracking Down Causes of Engine Failure
Engine Repair Options
Diagnosing An Engine that Won't Crank or Start
Diagnosing Engine Noise
Troubleshooting Low Oil Pressure
Oil Pump Diagnosis
Causes of High Oil Consumption
Engine Compression Testing
Engine Leakdown Testing
Engine Overheating: Causes & Cures
Why Head Gaskets Fail
Head Gasket Failure: Common Causes
Click here for more Engine Related articles
Mitchell 1 DIY eautorepair manuals